Who wins the $1 player challenge?

Matthew and Nate tentatively put the following on the board:
Who will have a better team of $1 players?
The premise is that Matthew and Nate will draft a team of $1 players from the AL & NL Tout Wars drafts. The teams will be scored using the standard 5×5 categories and each guy will field a team of 5 batters and 5 pitchers.

League site

Check out the 3-24-2011 podcast between 23:12-24:32 for this bet.
Check out the 3-31-2011 podcast between 25:07-34:19 for the player draft.

[polldaddy poll=4779562]