Who wins American Idol: Bowersox/Magnus/James or Dewyze?


Matthew and Nate put the following on the board:

Who wins American Idol: Crystal Bowersox/Casey James/Siobhan Magnus or Lee Dewyze?

Matthew reluctantly chose Crystal/Casey/Siobhan and Nate chose Dewyze.
UPDATE:
Just to make this bet even more bizarro, Nate allowed Matthew to add Casey James and Siobhan Magnus to his side of the bet.

Check out the 4-22-10 podcast between 23:51-27:03 for this bet.
Also check out the 4-23-10 podcast between 31:11-32:45 for the addition to this bet.